Guardians of Grail

zekjhiryyh

In Deng Xiaomang seems fake academic needs "irrefutable evidence" must collect and master all of the documentation, clear operational procedures for each step, the show witnesses and evidence, so that "the hitters" in the face of irrefutable evidence
, Fang finds its "pit teacher", with his ideas about counterfeiting, is gullible Internet rumors, due to negligence.
Deng Xiaomang also said that online information is an important channel for civil fraud.
and other agencies responsible for arbitration by an expert to be responsible for identification. generally without judicial intervention force, can be more peaceful, fair deal with the matter. "
"He did not find the most important evidence in the case,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], the mere easily seized an online" winners "and online idea for Mr. Yang Zutao individual speculation, it finds me 'pocketed honor', can not be justified." Deng
Identified on the microblogging Fang Deng Xiaomang "pit teacher" and receive the "open letter" insisted after the previous judge, also attracted some users questioned.
: "fake risk, evidence to be cautious." king in that academic fraud involving the reputation of others, so the crackdown by asking questions, it is necessary to grasp the chain of complete chain of evidence.
This session of the "winners", there are also many people winning the case, "why others can more than winning, you can not " Reporter access to the Ministry of Education in 2006 and 2005 awards to the discovery, reporting requirements vary.
"Private Enforcement has it difficult to overcome the limitations, such as those in the fake academic standards, certification qualifications, neutrality and credibility, are likely to be lacking." Zhang Ming made, to make China's academic crackdown more robust way to go
User Joker worried: "This is the anti-Fang 'authority', but whether it is now turned into another kind of authority " In this regard, Zhang Ming said Fang as "fake fighters" always speak up, even if the conclusion is not enough sometimes
This is called "pits division case,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]."
December 18,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], Fang and Deng Xiaomang were accepted an interview with China Youth Daily reporter.
"Fang finds Deng Xiaomang 'pit teacher' attitude should be more careful one o'clock." He believes that Fang should at least be found in the original material awards, award certificates and verified with the teacher after Yang Tsu Tao, and then express their views.
problem. "Fang said that the former term outstanding achievement award, Deng Xiaomang is obtained with others award.
"documented."
November 8, Deng Xiaomang published "Deng Xiaomang Open Letter to Mr. Fang Zhouzai" (hereinafter referred to as "open letter"), denying the "pit teacher," adding that counterfeiting should have enough solid evidence to openings, Fang said in this
power "leading role" stage, regardless of who is being fake batters are inevitably encounter difficulties.
Critical new translation "declared the Ministry of Education College of Humanities and Social Sciences Fourth Outstanding Achievement Award, willfully omitted book proofreader, Deng's mentor Professor Yang Zutao's name, the name of an individual translation philosophy class declaration and received the first prize,
Deng Xiaomang told reporters that he called "nobodies" no administrative title refers to the status and power of ordinary scholar, he is also one of a.
discussion of peace and mentality, "This is the most basic quality of the so-called academic fraud." Fang told reporters, exposing the fraud to be solid, emphasis on evidence, "but not an academic discussion exposing fraud, do not have to 'peace'." Deng
"There are questions about things, made their doubts itself is not wrong, but do not jump to conclusions, even finds unfair, his help, then pull out the 'knife' should also be true." Friends "Tao North" Simply expressed
's note) in its translated as "Kant's three
first made 'ironclad', rather inconsiderate. "Zhang Ming also said," Fang though influential, but after all he belongs to private parties, in the 'school official' powerful environment to one person alone
"This will reduce the 'friendly fire' probability, but also a minimum of respect for others." Civil forces play the leading role has its limitations, however, provoked the civil power beam in the context of academic fraud, "requires private individuals powerless before the crackdown
In 2006, "declared qualified" column, there are indeed requirements "cooperative research results must be signed by the first person reporting, without first applying himself signed the results are inadmissible."
"For scholars, once plagiarized articles were published, scholars tend to bear a huge loss of reputation, and has since difficult in the 'Community' within the base." Zhang Ming said, "Even if he Jiaolai, 'Community' there is also a school board
Fang and Deng Xiaomang two uncompromising, truth more debates blurred.
"This shows that the two co-winners, Fang said I pocketed honors and prizes,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], there is no convincing basis." Deng Xiaomang said.
name, I want to ask,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], Mr. Yang Zutao award certificates you have on hand "" As long as Mr. Yang Zutao out explicitly say a word, things will get to the bottom. "Deng Xiaomang said,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], but" more than three years, we have almost no contact.
"There is no new evidence to make me change my mind, there is no supplement." Fang said.
China People's University political science professor,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], said Zhang Ming evaluation, which to some extent is the Chinese academic crackdown embarrassing situation in miniature.
authority, but in the public's influence but can not be overlooked.
Fang becoming another "authority"
This year on November 1, known as "fake fighters" said Fang () on the microblogging references online statement, identified Deng Xiaomang "pit teacher."
.
years, Fang is famed country of the "fake hero."
As for the bonus, "If Deng Xiaomang said is true," He wants to "quoted someone saying," said he, "pocketed bonuses" and apologized.
Deng Xiaomang posted herewith also awards photo, printed above "Deng Xiaomang translation, YANG Zu pottery school."
"Relative power and influence ', academia and government', these people obviously belong 'punches', they were attacked by some unknown later, back in the exculpatory and confrontation, are relatively weak much." Deng Xiaomang think
"Pit Master" or not, is still doubtful "open letter," said the Ministry of Education declared the first author only, so Deng Xiaomang YANG Zu Tao will be in the return as a "collaborator" and before submission "by Yang
Although they still stuck to their guns, but all that "academic fraud is not easy."
As for the "pocketed the money,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]," the letter disclosed that the Ministry of Education did not award bonuses, but by Wuhan University as a result of the award, equivalent to 40,000 yuan, is half points were playing in the Tang, Young's account of
Zhang Ming said that as China's academic crackdown mainly rely civil power, which means the strike is often doomed to more "vigorous", due to the relative lack of accurate sources of information, the conclusions are "less accurate", behavior is also more difficult to
Mans agree on this point Professor Fang's view, he said, since the current is still based mainly civil power to carry fake, then you should definitely its positive effect.
pocketed the honor and bonuses.
After a couple of head teacher. "
Although at that time the Ministry of Education only allowed one person reporting, but does not exclude the collaborators will be included in the announcement, in fact, does more than one channel announced the "winners", "I do have a fine print of the" fourth
constraints, therefore, inevitably presents "a mess," the fake situation.
Deng Xiaomang that Fang misreading of the "open letter,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]."
I do not know Mr. Yang Zutao how to think, he never directly told me. "by Deng Xiaomang commission issued" open letter "to Mr. Wang Li confirmed that Mr. Yang Zutao so far this is not too clear statement.
"At present, China's academic crackdown ecology is their own lack of self-discipline academic consensus, academic ethics committees and other official institutions 'omission', so when encounter academic fraud, the academia and the government jointly by the crackdown to do business, it
. "" This is a public resource according to master doing verification. "December 18, Fang explained that" from Mr. Yang Zutao recently wrote an article revealed the information, and publicly available information to see, I think Deng is
struggle. "Deng Xiaomang also say so.
November 9, Fang said in a blog Responses to "Open Letter", admits "I did not see the award certificate is how to write," but, "then the Ministry of Education issued the" winners "and the winner is only one person Deng Xiaomang
session of the China Academic Humanities and Social Sciences Outstanding Achievement Award register ", the first prize is a column in philosophy class I and Tao Yang Tsu two names." Deng Xiaomang said.
made 'ironclad', the resistance can be imagined, and, speaking from a legal perspective, there may be illegal. "" Academic institutions like now paralyzed does not work, any allegations and arguments are easy to become and factional bickering
Netizen "Kun Yuan-ming," also questioned, Fang said in response to the "open letter" is there "If Deng Xiaomang said is true," and other words, "but whether it is true is not precisely identify the fake basic job " Ten
Fang admits: "academic crackdown by the personal power,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], energy and resources are limited, not authority, not the norm, is the system is missing the upset." As to how this should be done,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], the king has called solid style crackdown
issue "clearly lacks cautious."
can learn from foreign experience in scholarship, in the current academic has bred a common concept of right and wrong and academic moral bottom line of the "academic community" is a feasible way.
In foreign universities "academic community" within the academic fraud issues for the identification and treatment, already had a more mature operating rules.
While in 2005 this column provides only "cooperative research first signed, must be university teachers and researchers," There is no limit on the number of people reporting.
"Only heard Yang advanced age, hearing bad eyesight, inconvenience bother,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], it can not provide more information." Reporter tried to contact Mr. Yang Zutao, but as of press time, no response.
Xiao Mans said, "Now award certificate has been issued on the Internet, why does not he go about it " In this regard, Fang responded by saying, "I saw on the Internet presented the award certificate photo, Yang said that the above
inevitably fell on the 'private individuals' body. "Deng Xiaomang in the" open letter "proposed" Academic fraud is not easy, especially for the powerless nobodies "of the language, it seems that is a reflection of the folk
相关的主题文章:

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]